Skip to content


Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer signed a controversial new immigration bill today which is said to be the toughest in the country.  During his administration, George W Bush pushed for immigration reform. The Senate killed it.


Exposing a deep lack of support among Bush’s own Republicans, the bill fell 14 votes short of the 60 needed in the 100-member Senate to advance toward a final vote.

A crestfallen Bush conceded defeat and said he was moving on to other issues such as balancing the federal budget when it became clear the immigration legislation would not be revived during the final 18 months of his two-term presidency.


Senator John McCain, who co-authored an immigration reform bill with Sen. Ted Kennedy in 2005 called the new legislation in Arizona “a very important step forward.”


Today could have been an opportunity for the Republican Party to seek the Latino vote.  John McCain caved in due to pressure from Conservatives.


Governor Brewer claims this bill will strengthen existing laws and protect citizens of the state without leading to racial profiling or discrimination. This bill  is “aimed at identifying and deporting illegal immigrants.”  This will also make the jobs in the Arizona police force extremely difficult, unless you’re Sheriff Joe Arpaio who is infamous for stopping and asking for documents to prove immigrant status. This was before the bill was signed.


The governor’s signature on this divisive bill has already ignited protests from advocates of immigration reform.


Governor Brewer said she’s “against racial profiling” while at the same time, she just legalized racial profiling. Make no mistake about it.  Racial profiling can be done without consequence to the officer.  She said:

Let me be clear though my signature today represents my steadfast support for enforcing the law both against illegal immigration and against racial profiling. I will not tolerate racial discrimination or profiling in Arizona.

Is the Governor referring to this kind of discrimination that she said she will not tolerate that is already happening in Arizona:

For more than 15 years, Phoenix New Times has reported on Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio’s serious abuse of power. The self-described “Toughest Sheriff in America” has fostered horrendous jail conditions, reckless police operations, and carried out personal vendettas against political rivals and members of the press. In the last year or more, he has also appointed himself enforcer of the nation’s immigration laws in Arizona, and a whole new series of problems has emerged. Foremost, he and his deputies have violated the Constitutional rights of brown-skinned U.S. citizens and have committed outright cruelty against the undocumented. This year, the U.S. Justice Department has commenced an investigation of his actions.

New York Times:

The law, which opponents and critics alike said was the broadest and strictest immigration measure in the country in generations, would make the failure to carry immigration documents a crime. It would also give the police broad power to detain anyone suspected of being in the country illegally. Opponents have decried it as an open invitation for harassment and discrimination against Hispanics regardless of their citizenship status.

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Just a thought…We are not supposed to, as Americans, be detained without being charged. John Yoo was the architect of putting into action the legalizing of torture.  We are now putting into action the legalizing of racial profiling and detaining people on mere suspicion alone.  Are we supposed to have faith in the decisions every officer in Arizona makes?  Sheriff Joe must be celebrating tonight.


Posted in Politics.

Tagged with , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , .

  • http://momentarylucidity.com/blog TheTXI

    I had already posted about this issue on my own blog previous to Gov. Brewer’s signature (god that was a train wreck of a press conference).

    She did quite a dance up there trying to reiterate that racial profiling is illegal and that Arizona law enforcement authorities do not racially profile while trying to explain how someone would even be able to try and enforce this law without applying some form of racial discrimination.

    All I would like to know is…”What does an illegal immigrant look like?” What are the criteria a law enforcement officer is supposed to use to form a suspicion over the legal status of someone walking down the street? And before someone tries to say otherwise, yes the bill does not require that you already be stopped for some other reason (such as a traffic stop). If you are walking down the street and you apparently fit the description of an illegal immigrant to some law enforcement officer’s mind, he has the authority to now stop you and ask for your papers.

    And if you don’t have your papers, you go to jail. After your arrest if they then determine that you are of legal status (at least a legal alien) but were not carrying proper ID, you can still go to prison for that crime.

    This is going to be a disaster in Arizona. With all of the extra work put on the police to enforce this by arresting and jailing people that aren’t carrying ID, and the inevitable lawsuits challenging an arrest or challenging the constitutionality of the bill itself, I would love to know how Arizona (a state that is so in debt that they have considered selling the capitol office building) plans to give the necessary resources to these police departments.

  • http://twitter.com/notkhayyam/status/12747064357 notkhayyam

    Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona http://ki.am/cnDXT8 #classythinking! http://ow.ly/179WsZ

  • http://twitter.com/dennis_jernberg/status/12745609551 Dennis Jernberg

    RT @iamkhayyam
    Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona http://ki.am/cnDXT8 #classythinking! #fail #stpuid

    • http://twitter.com/iamkhayyam/status/12745495713 Khayyam Wakil

      Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona http://ki.am/cnDXT8 #classythinking!

  • http://twitter.com/ronbonn/status/12745597937 Aaron Bonner

    RT @iamkhayyam: Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona http://ki.am/cnDXT8 #classythinking!

  • http://twitter.com/p2blogs/status/12738918001 P2 Blogs

    RT @Rocky1542: RT @AlphaAnt1: RT @FreakOutNation: Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona #p2 http://is.gd/bFvanhttp://bit.ly/8ZGnJ5

  • http://twitter.com/lmarshall5/status/12736433326 lisa abraham marshal

    RT @AlphaAnt1: RT @FreakOutNation: Racial Profiling Is Now Legal In Arizona #p2 #p2b http://is.gd/bFvan

  • Hank

    If I did this right, this interview is a good, calm, logical statement from a knowledgeable source. I agree with him. They are on the front lines. Who are we to question good faith efforts to confront the difficulties they are faced with IN THEIR HOMETOWNS?

    http://video.foxnews.com/v/4163566/obama-slams-arizona-immigration-bill#/v/4161988/sheriff-we-need-help/?playlist_id=86856

  • Hank

    “We are not supposed to, as Americans, be detained without being charged.”

    And as I understand it, you won’t be. How can you blame the people that live in this state from taking steps to try to prevent the rampant crime that has invaded their state at the hands of illegal immigrants?

    How understanding would you be if that had been your husband or son that was gunned down a few weeks back on his own property by an illegal immigrant?

    It’s not racial profiling. It’s common sense.

  • http://www.polrev.com ChrisG

    Blah blah blah. What, is “racial profiling” now the newest “race card”?

    How many times do you lefties intend on using THIS now that you way over-played the other card?

    The logic is simple:
    LEGAL: you are fine.
    ILLEGAL: you will be deported.

    If I can’t get out of paying fines for the tickets I get, why the hell should illegals be allowed to stay?

    What do ya think ILLEGAL means?

  • Pingback: uberVU - social comments